Forbes: Geithner’s Reform Pitch

Sep 23, 2009
In The News

Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner came to Capitol Hill Wednesday to talk up the administration’s plans for a Consumer Financial Protection Agency and address lawmakers’ concerns about firms that are too big to fail. But in Geithner brushing aside worries about over-regulation, he seems to have created more questions than answers.

In his prepared testimony before the House Financial Services Committee, Geithner argued that the need for a "dedicated, consolidated consumer protection agency" is clear because the old system failed to save consumers from feeling the brunt of the economic crisis.
"Did that system work?" Geithner asked rhetorically during the hearing. "How well did it do?"

But lawmakers, particularly Republicans, remain concerned about regulatory mission creep. They worry that a new agency will create an increased burden on community banks. They’re concerned about a reshuffling of regulatory powers as the crisis continues, and about turf wars between the agencies.

"You can’t expect them to do anything different," Geithner said, in response to criticism that the Federal Reserve, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. and other bank regulators are concerned about losing their current supervisory authority. "Our job is to figure out what’s right for the country."

The Treasury Secretary says that the administration has dropped its proposal that financial institutions offer "plain vanilla" versions of finanicial products, which critics have argued takes too much risk out of the system.
In his prepared remarks, Geithner said the administration does not support the creation of a "fixed list" of Tier 1 financial holding companies, also known as firms that are too big to fail. However, he also said that identifying these firms "will not convey a government subsidy," leaving open an important question–how will the government treat large interconnected firms that could bring down the entire financial system.

By identifying these firms, the government could create an implicit guarantee that it will rush to the rescue of an ailing company, as it has done in the past year with Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, Citigroup, American International Group, General Motors and others. Lawmakers argued that an administration with good intentions could actually end up giving more power to large firms.

"It was the big boys that damn near killed us all, not the little players," said Rep. Frank Lucas, R-Okla.

Recent Posts


Sep 24, 2024
Economy

Gensler and Peirce Disagree on Treasury Clearing Implementation

Washington, DC – Today, at a Financial Services hearing entitled Oversight of the Securities and Exchange Commission, Congressman Lucas, SEC Chair Gary Gensler, and SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce discussed the need to extend Treasury clearing timelines. While Chair Gensler did not say, Commissioner Peirce agreed with Congressman Lucas that there is a need to extend these […]



Sep 23, 2024
Press

Lucas, Mullin Welcome $5.5 Million Investment to OSU to Enhance Weather Prediction

Cheyenne, OK – The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) awarded Oklahoma State University (OSU) $5.5 million as part of the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2024. The purpose of these funds is to increase knowledge about local weather systems in the lower atmosphere, enabling the safe integration of small Unmanned Aerial Vehicles and Advanced […]



Sep 18, 2024
Press

Lucas Honors NASA’s Hidden Figures at Congressional Gold Medal Ceremony

Washington, DC – Today, House Science, Space, and Technology Committee Chairman Frank Lucas attended a Congressional Gold Medal Ceremony, where he had the opportunity to honor the Hidden Figures, a group of women crucial to the space race. These women helped calculate the Apollo 11 mission to land the first astronaut on the moon. Medals […]